Merch is usually the first line cut when a budget gets tight. Digital ad spend rarely is, even though nobody's actually sat down and compared what each one costs per impression. So we did the maths: a branded tote bag next to a LinkedIn ad, on the same footing, cost for every time someone actually sees the thing.
If you're weighing promotional products for business against another quarter of digital spend, this is the comparison that should inform that call, not which platform has the bigger marketing team.
A $6 tote bag costs roughly $0.001 per impression over its lifetime. The average LinkedIn ad costs $0.056 per impression. That's not a rounding difference, it's a 56x gap, and it holds up even before you factor in brand recall or how people actually feel about receiving the thing.
Promotional Products vs Digital Advertising at a Glance
Here's the comparison nobody puts side by side, because the two are usually budgeted, tracked, and reported by entirely different teams.
Cost per impression
$0.001 to $0.004, tote bags to premium fleece
$0.003 to $0.056, Google Display to LinkedIn
Brand recall
85% can name the advertiser after the fact
Not consistently tracked at this granularity
Brand favorability
78% report a more favorable view of the brand
Not typically measured per impression
Lifespan of each impression
Averages 3,300 impressions across the product's lifetime
Ends when the ad's flight dates end
Measurability
Estimated from consumer survey data
Tracked in real time by the ad platform
What "Cost Per Impression" Actually Means for a Physical Product
A digital impression is a single ad load, tracked and reported the moment it happens. A merch impression is different. It's every time a product gets seen, worn, or used after it's handed over, not just the moment someone receives it.
That's harder to measure than a server log, which is exactly why it gets left out of most budget conversations. ASI's Global Advertising Impressions Study surveyed close to 5,000 consumers across the US, Canada, Mexico and Europe to actually put a number on it. Their finding: the average promotional product generates around 3,300 impressions over its lifetime. Not per campaign. Per product.
The Numbers, Product by Product
Cost per impression drops fast once a product earns repeat use.
A $6 tote bag gets roughly 5,000 impressions across its lifetime, which works out close to $0.001 per impression. Premium items like fleece cost more upfront but are still built for repeat wear, closer to $0.004 per impression. Other industry data puts branded merchandise more broadly at $0.003 to $0.004 per impression, a wider range than ASI's headline figure. We're including both rather than quoting whichever number looks best, because a range that survives scrutiny is more useful than a stat that doesn't.
Either way, we're talking about fractions of a cent.
What Digital Advertising Costs for the Same Reach
Average CPM across platforms sits at $8.50 in 2026, up 12% year over year. Broken down by platform, Meta averages $13.48. LinkedIn averages $56, the most expensive major platform, and notably the default channel for most B2B advertisers reading this. Google Display Network is the cheapest of the group at $3.12, and YouTube runs up to $36 in competitive categories like finance.
Convert those into cost per impression and LinkedIn works out to roughly $0.056. Meta lands around $0.013. Even Google Display, the cheapest option here, still costs more than three times what a tote bag does.
Impressions Aren't the Whole Story
Cheap impressions only matter if people remember and like them. On that front, merch has numbers digital struggles to match. 85% of people can name the advertiser on a promotional product they own. 76% are more likely to do business with a brand after receiving merch from them. 78% report a more favorable view of a brand that gives useful, well-made merch. 94% say they actually like receiving promotional products, a sentiment score no ad format gets close to, because no ad format is something people choose to keep using.
Put plainly, these are cheap impressions that get remembered, not scrolled past.
Where This Breaks Down
We're not going to pretend this is a clean win for merch, because it isn't. Digital ads offer targeting, frequency control, and real-time measurement a tote bag can't touch. You can't A/B test a fleece. And merch impressions are estimated from survey data, not tracked the way a digital impression is, which is a real methodology gap worth being upfront about.
The honest read: merch and digital aren't competing for the same job. The cost-per-impression case for merch is stronger than most budget owners assume, not a replacement for the case for digital.
Before You Judge Your Merch Budget by CPM Alone, Check This
- Whether the products in your program are built to be kept, not just handed out once
- Whether you're comparing merch and digital on the same unit, cost per impression, not cost per unit shipped
- Whether your catalog leans toward items with long lifespans, like bags, drinkware, and outerwear, over single-use giveaways
- Whether recall and favorability are part of the budget conversation, not just reach
- Whether your merch supplier can actually get product to every region your team or clients sit in
FAQ
What is cost per impression for promotional products?
It's the total cost of a branded item divided by the number of times it's seen, worn, or used over its lifetime. A $6 tote bag that gets around 5,000 impressions works out to roughly $0.001 per impression.
How does promotional product ROI compare to digital advertising?
On cost per impression, well-chosen merch usually beats digital. LinkedIn's average CPM converts to around $0.056 per impression, compared to $0.001 to $0.004 for merch like tote bags and fleece. Digital still wins on targeting and measurement, merch wins on cost and longevity.
Why is LinkedIn advertising so expensive compared to other platforms?
LinkedIn's $56 average CPM reflects its B2B audience and professional targeting options, both of which command a premium over broader consumer platforms like Google Display, which averages $3.12.
Do promotional products still work in a digital-first marketing strategy?
Yes, as a complement rather than a substitute. Merch delivers cheap, long-running impressions with strong recall (85%) and favorability (78%), which digital ads don't replicate on their own.
The cost-per-impression case for merch only holds up if the product is worth keeping. Boxaroo builds promotional products designed to last, stores them ahead of when you need them, and ships from Singapore and Barcelona so they land wherever your team is.
Browse Promotional Products Request a Demo